
A petition for a proposed amendment to the Pasadena City Charter that would repeal and replace the city’s rent stabilization and eviction protections has been found “insufficient” to go before Pasadena voters, falling 135 valid signatures short of the 13,743 required, based on figures in a letter dated Friday from City Clerk Mark Jomsky to the petition’s proponent.
While the Pasadena Tenants Union declared the news “a huge relief to tenants,” supporters said they will likely ask for a recount.
The Los Angeles County Registrar-Recorder/County Clerk’s Office, which verified signatures on behalf of the city, found 13,608 valid signatures among the 28,214 submitted, according to the letter, addressed to proponent Alan L. Bair.
Because that number is less than the 15% minimum of Pasadena voters required, Jomsky wrote, the petition is found to be insufficient in accordance with Elections Code Section 9114.
Simon Gibbons of the landlords’ group Pasadena Housing Providers issued a statement Monday.
“At this time, the Pasadena Fair Housing Charter Amendment is 135 signatures short of the target required to be certified for the 2028 ballot. This is less than one percent below the target,” the statement said.
“More than fourteen thousand signatures were found to be insufficient, which is unusual for a ballot measure.”
Under California Elections Code Section 9255(c)(1), the petition must contain valid signatures from at least 15% of the city’s registered voters to be deemed sufficient for submitting the proposed amendment to Pasadena voters. Jomsky wrote that, in accordance with Elections Code Section 9256, the Secretary of State reported 91,619 registered voters in Pasadena when the petition’s Notice of Intention to Circulate was published March 30, setting the minimum at 13,743.
Bair submitted the petition for signature verification Sept. 9. The City Clerk’s Office requested that the county conduct a full check of all signatures under Elections Code Section 9114, Jomsky wrote. The county’s 30-business-day examination period ended Thursday.
In a certification dated Thursday and signed by Registrar-Recorder/County Clerk Dean C. Logan, the county reported 14,606 signatures found not sufficient.
According to a petition statistics sheet enclosed with Jomsky’s letter, the largest category, 4,074 signatures, was rejected because the signer was not registered. Another 3,217 were rejected as out of district, 2,902 for mismatched signatures and 2,336 as duplicates.
Smaller numbers were rejected for a different address (888), canceled (403), printed signature (253), “fatal pending” (102), no address (96), invalid registration date (95), miscellaneous (88), PO box or mailing address (38), information entered by circulator (23), missing signature on the petition (18), underage at signing (13) and out-of-county address (seven). Of 60 signature withdrawal requests, 53 signatures were withdrawn; those 53 are counted in the 14,606 total.
“The County of Los Angeles has a formal process to allow for a full review of these signatures, and we are working with an election integrity attorney to go through this process,” the Pasadena Housing Providers statement said. “The County’s offices will be busy with the November election, so it is possible we will need the entire 81-day timeline that is allowed.”
Jomsky’s letter cited California Government Code Sections 7924.100 through 7924.110 as provisions that may assist the proponent in reviewing the findings. Under those sections, initiative petitions are not public records, nor is a memorandum prepared by a county elections official indicating which registered voters signed a petition. When a petition is found insufficient, the proponent and a representative designated in writing may examine the petition and memorandum to determine which signatures were disqualified and why.
That examination must begin no later than 21 days after certification of insufficiency and conclude no later than 60 days after it begins, a combined maximum of 81 days. If it is not concluded within five business days, the proponents must reimburse the county elections official for costs incurred to continue it, with costs estimated and deposited daily. The law defines reimbursable cost as cost in addition to or greater than general operating costs. Proponents are entitled to a refund of any deposit exceeding the cost of the examination. The official is not bound by any cost estimate and may, on a pro rata basis, bill proponents for additional actual expense or refund any excess paid, depending on the final actual cost. Money not required to be refunded is deposited in the appropriate public treasury. The statute states that nothing in the reimbursement provision permits a county elections official to delay or obstruct the examination.
Jomsky’s letter also quoted Elections Code Section 9114: “If the petition is found insufficient, no further action shall be taken. However, the failure to secure sufficient signatures, shall not preclude the filing of a new petition on the same subject, at a later date.”
“Pasadena Housing Providers remains committed to fair and equal representation in housing policies that affect the residents of Pasadena, and to a transparent approach to rental regulation,” the statement said. “We look forward to giving residents an opportunity to vote on this in 2028.”
Meanwhile, the Pasadena Tenants Union said “This is a huge victory for Pasadena residents who are committed to protecting the housing security of our neighbors.”











