
The appeal, filed Monday by attorney Richard McDonald on behalf of residential neighbors along South Grand Avenue, challenges the city’s six-month review of events held at the historic Maxwell House, 55 S. Grand Ave.
“The Hearing Officer acted beyond his authority” by modifying a permit condition and allowing the center to expand activities at the property, the appeal alleges.
The Western Justice Center received approval in April to hold weddings, celebrations and similar private events at the Maxwell House under a Conditional Use Permit (CUP). The permit allows a maximum of 18 such events annually, spread across no more than 14 weekends.
A condition of the CUP required a public review six months after the center’s first event to determine whether it had complied with restrictions governing noise, parking, attendance, hours and outdoor activities.
Following a Sept. 2 hearing, the hearing officer found the permit’s conditions remained valid and modified Condition No. 10 to state that gatherings connected to the primary business activities of the Western Justice Center and nonprofit organizations leasing office space on its campus are not subject to the conditional use permit.
Examples listed in the revised condition include training sessions, fundraisers, award ceremonies and luncheons. Weddings, celebrations and similar life events remain subject to the 18-event annual limit.
The neighbors contend the modification improperly enlarged the number and type of events that can be held at the property. They also argue that the center should not be allowed to conduct such gatherings during regular business hours.
The appeal further challenges the city’s finding that the project is exempt from additional environmental review under a California Environmental Quality Act exemption for existing facilities.
Neighbors also allege continuing problems involving noise from the outdoor patio, excessive street parking, incomplete posting of event hours and insufficient documentation of attendance figures. They asked the city to impose additional conditions addressing those concerns.
Under the permit, outdoor music and microphone use must end by 6 p.m., and amplified music is restricted to indoor areas. Events must comply with Pasadena’s noise ordinance.
The permit also requires at least 37 parking spaces in a lot at 116 South Grand Ave. The center must maintain attendance records, publish an event schedule and provide security personnel for each event. Attendance is generally limited to 125 people, although as many as one-quarter of the annual events may have up to 150 guests.
The hearing officer’s decision had been scheduled to take effect Tuesday. The appeal sends the dispute to the Pasadena Board of Zoning Appeals for review. A hearing date was not listed in the filing.











