Latest Guides

Government

Staff Recommends Keeping Artificial Turf at Villa Parke, Robinson Park

Published on Monday, October 12, 2026 | 6:00 am
 

The city recommends retaining artificial turf at Villa Parke and Robinson Park, citing greater field availability and lower water and maintenance needs despite higher long-term costs and environmental concerns.

The City Council will consider the recommendation Tuesday. Staff proposes replacing the existing surfaces with recyclable artificial turf systems that exclude PFAS from manufacturing and use natural infill materials.

Villa Parke’s soccer field replacement has a $975,000 allocation. Robinson Park’s multipurpose field is approaching the end of its useful life but has no replacement funding and is included for comparison and future planning.

The recommendation follows requests from the council and Municipal Services Committee to compare natural grass, reinforced hybrid grass and newer artificial turf systems.

Staff estimates natural grass would cost approximately $1.53 million over 10 years at Villa Parke, compared with approximately $2.43 million for artificial turf. The artificial turf estimate includes replacement in the 10th year.

Artificial turf would provide approximately 3,120 prime-time available hours annually, compared with 2,340 for lighted natural grass fields. Estimated annual maintenance and renovation costs would be approximately $16,646 for artificial turf and $37,785 for natural grass.

Installing natural grass would require a four- to six-month closure, compared with two to three months for artificial turf. Grass would also require periodic closures for recovery and renovation.

Officials said Pasadena Unified School District and Rose Bowl facilities have limited availability to accommodate displaced programs because of existing school, athletic and event schedules.

Pasadena manages 22 dedicated athletic fields with one three-person sports field maintenance crew. Natural and hybrid grass would require more routine staff time and equipment, according to the report.

Hybrid grass combines living turf with synthetic reinforcement. Staff estimated its initial installation cost at approximately $2.2 million, but Pasadena-specific renovation and replacement costs have not been established.

The report acknowledges natural grass generally provides a cooler surface and avoids synthetic turf materials. Artificial turf raises concerns involving heat, microplastics, PFAS, stormwater and disposal.

Pasadena’s Public Health Department is developing extreme-heat guidelines for outdoor youth recreation on both surfaces. Proposed measures include on-site monitoring of temperature, humidity, wind and solar radiation, hydration breaks and activity modifications.

Staff plans a two-year natural grass trial on approximately 25,000 square feet at Villa Parke’s multipurpose field. Four seed varieties would receive identical irrigation, mowing, fertilization and maintenance to compare wear, recovery and staffing needs.

Villa Parke’s artificial turf was installed between 2009 and 2011 and replaced under warranty in 2018. It is nearing the end of its useful life.

No additional appropriation is needed for the proposed artificial turf replacement at Villa Parke. Selecting natural or hybrid grass would require additional funding, according to the report submitted by Parks, Recreation and Community Services Director Koko Panossian.

Get our daily Pasadena newspaper in your email box. Free.

Get all the latest Pasadena news, more than 10 fresh stories daily, 7 days a week at 7 a.m.

Make a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *